Theodore Wafer (R) and Renisha McBride (L) |
I just can't. Involuntary Manslaughter, MAYBE, but what evidence proved Murder 2?
MORE: Suburban Detroit homeowner convicted of second-degree murder for killing woman who showed up drunk on porch: http://t.co/parUipYRxw
— The Associated Press (@AP) August 7, 2014
Note: looks as though AP bowed to pressure and removed their article which offended some. The truth in these cases does that sometimes.Closing Arguments: This link has all the information related to closing arguments. I am truly so disgusted with this Judge and the investigation that I don't really even care to address much of it. The Judge's mother went to prison on corruption charges and it appears the apple presiding over the Wafer trial did not fall far from that tree.
A few highlights (in bold) from Rumpole's summary at above link with my comments below them:
"judge says no dispute mcbride injured, bleeding .."
The above statement is a reference to defense asking that "looking for help" be left out of jury instructions. I will just interject here that the autopsy did not note any other injury aside from the gunshot wound. No one, especially Wafer, heard Renisha calling out for help. No proof whatsoever McBride was looking for help.
"judge says she has not given jury instructions in relation to breaking and entering. the whole issue is whether someone was attack. in home
judge says there was no attack. pros. says def is going to infer there and that law contrary to tha
judge says you still need an attack for no duty to retreat (michigan self defense law)"
Dear crackhead Judge, with all due respect:
Sec. 21c. (1) In cases in which section 2 of the self-defense act does not apply, the common law of this state applies except that the duty to retreat before using deadly force is not required if an individual is in his or her own dwelling or within the curtilage of that dwelling."In Michigan the meaning of curtilage lias been extended to include more than an enclosure near the house. People v. Taylor, 2 Mich. 250"
Not to mention, and contrary to what the Judge stated to the prosecution and defense, an actual "attack" does not need to take place in order for a homeowner to have reasonable and honest fear of great bodily harm or to perceive imminent danger.
The investigation into this case was so inept - in fact, to call what transpired an investigation would be a joke. So, suffice it to say the Judge is guaranteeing a successful appeal by not allowing the jury to consider breaking and entering. There is no possible way she could reasonably deduce that this was not Renisha McBride's intent when no steps were taken by investigators to assess the incident scene at all, or at least not in a timely manner. By the time evidence was taken the entire scene was contaminated.
"Hathaway said that jurors can only consider evidence that was properly admitted in the case."
What a total joke this case was. Wafer may or may not be guilty of something, but I can't even render an honest opinion based on the facts as they were presented. My gut feeling is Wafer lied and said it was an accident because most people believe accidents can be forgiven. He shot himself in the foot and now he is facing the consequences of that misguided false admission. Who knows though - this has been a pathetic look into our American justice system.
Day Eight - Wafer takes stand again today to testify.
Day Seven - Theodore Wafer testified today. Other links from courtroom https://twitter.com/idabeewells - https://twitter.com/oralandar_DN
The #TheodoreWafer testimony in the #RenishaMcBride case is intensely emotional. Even the tweets are dramatic: https://t.co/ick0wCMevQ
— Steve Friess (@SteveFriess) August 4, 2014
**** Case Timeline and documents HERE Discuss this case at Random Topics Follow trial on Twitter @thetrialfile ****
Also new on this blog: "Renisha McBride: Young and Thuggin"
Renisha McBride is not on trial...Theodore Wafer is on trial. During this trial the defense attorney was allowed to ask witnesses about a profile name for Renisha McBride "Young and Thuggin"
Day Six - Did not put up feed for day six, will find and post later.
Day Five (also here)of the Theodore Wafer Trial - the trial picked up the pace today with a few interesting facts coming to light that I had not heard before. Apparently Renisha had $156.00 on her person the night she died. In some mysterious way, a $100 bill that was in her pocket when she was shot, was not there when her body was received by the medical examiner. Renisha's mother, Monica McBride testified that she was given the $100 bill by the medical examiner, but not the $56.00. In testimony late yesterday an audio was played from inside the squad car at the scene of Renisha's death. An officer is heard talking about the $100 bill. He is also heard talking about how he somehow contaminated the scene.
jury back in..monica mcbride on stand for pros. she says she gave renisha the $100 bill. def atty cross exam her about nov. 8 vigil
— oralandar brand-wms (@oralandar_DN) July 30, 2014
Prosecution rested and Werner Spitz, the renowned pathologist from the Phil Spector and Casey Anthony trials took the stand as the 1st witness for the defense. Dr. Spitz who has an extensive CV testified that both Renisha's hands were swollen which could be attributed to banging on Wafer's door and also to post mortem processes. Dr. Spitz also pointed out there was a fresh trail of blood originating from Renisha's left hand. This tells me the wound is something that happened shortly before her death, and not at the crash.
now looking at pic of mcbride's left hand and says it "looks swollen to me"..fresh trail of blood on her left hand that comes from the hand
— oralandar brand-wms (@oralandar_DN) July 30, 2014
When asked about McBride's toxicology, which showed her blood alcohol at 0.218, Spitz said said she would have had to consume between 10 and 11 shots of vodka or, if she drank beer, that would be the same number in bottles within one hour. He said that if she drank over two hours, for each hour she would have had to drink one more shot or one more bottle. He said she would burn off one unit per hour. (via Damron at Liveblog)Earlier, whether or not Renisha was shot at close range was testified to by ME Kesha:
kesha says no evidence of close range "discharge" but that she was shot at distance of 3 feet or less..no soot, no gun powder on her face
— oralandar brand-wms (@oralandar_DN) July 30, 2014
Finally, a must watch video from today's proceedings - this is the detective in charge of the Renisha McBride crime scene. Seriously, watch the VIDEO
**** Case Timeline and documents HERE Discuss this case at Random Topics Follow trial on Twitter @thetrialfile ****
Day Four of the Theodore Wafer Trial - the reporting by the person I usually link to was very scattered and uninformative today, so I am going to link to a blog with a combination of all reporters who were in the courtroom today - both tweets and the live blog. He also outlines the highlights, which were not really relevant to the outcome, in my opinion.
Day Three (looking for working link) of the Theodore Wafer Trial - Davonte Bines, a co-worker of Renisha testifies. A cell phone expert goes over Renisha McBrides cell phone records for November 1 and November 2.
Astonishing from today's trial: The cell phone expert testified that it was highly unlikely any conversation occurred during 12:35 a.m. and 12:59 a.m. calls, but said it was a possibility. Said he never called those numbers during his investigation to find out more information.
**** Case Timeline and documents HERE Discuss this case at Random Topics Follow trial on Twitter @thetrialfile ****
Tweets of Interest from today's proceedings (also see a great breakdown of the witnesses so far at The Trial File):
@IamPolarDude @ginadamron Yep pic.twitter.com/vTVCE8d4Cn
— Re-news It (@Re_Newsit) July 28, 2014
Davonta Bynes takes stand in #TheodoreWafer #RenishaMcBride. Nice of him to dress up for court. This makes me crazy! pic.twitter.com/ahn92JLgzy
— Cathy (@courtchatter) July 28, 2014
More as the day goes on....Day 2: live.freep.com Theodore Wafer Trial - The reporter doing the live blog had some technical difficulties, so not all of the trial is contained here. Today brought no major revelations and court will not re-convene until Monday morning. All in all, it seems the investigation was on trial today...
I don't know what happened between #RenishaMcBride and #TheodoreWafer ...but the police royally screwed up this investigation.
— Lou (@Louis2M2) July 24, 2014
I knew defense stated that investigation was bad. I never realized it was going to be this bad. Shame on you Dearborn PD #RenishaMcBride
— The Trial File (@TheTrialFile) July 24, 2014
Call it shoddy police work if u want but, Mi Castle Doctrine doesn't require a Law & Order CSI investign when its cut & dry #RenishaMcBride
— Polar Dude (@IamPolarDude) July 24, 2014
Instead of copying and pasting, I am just going to link to today's live blog - click here and make sure you begin at "oldest" post first at the bottom of the scroller. Case Timeline and documents HERE Discuss this case at Random Topics Follow trial on Twitter @thetrialfile - and thanks to Nettles for this:
.@JaJasTweets Here is video of today's testimony with audio of Wafer's initial stmt to police. http://t.co/s2Kknmg1CF
— Annette (@Nettles18) July 24, 2014
Look how close her feet are to the wall. Was her face in the screen when he shot her? #Wafer #McBride pic.twitter.com/lnpooeSRd1
— Annette (@Nettles18) July 23, 2014
Follow the @freep live blog for updates in the trial of Theodore Wafer, charged in the death of #RenishaMcBride. http://t.co/WVhu2QqGv3
— Gina Damron (@ginadamron) July 24, 2014
Below are live tweets from Gina Damron who is in the court room for the Theodore Wafer trial. I've added other links of interest as well. Please check back often for updates as this will be the only blog on the trial until after Prosecution's case has rested.
KEY point in my opinion.....someone else knows what went on that night....I hope they have an idea of who those people are:
Case Timeline and documents HERE Discuss this case at Random Topics Follow trial on Twitter @thetrialfile
Day 1: live.freep.com
KEY point in my opinion.....someone else knows what went on that night....I hope they have an idea of who those people are:
wafer looks outside and sees not 1 person but 2/ more people..the door was shaking..people were trying to get in, wafer believed, says atty
— oralandar brand-wms (@oralandar_DN) July 23, 2014
Compare hearing a few months ago to today's witness testimonies: Part I Part II (audio is rough at beginning of Part II but clears up when testimony begins)Case Timeline and documents HERE Discuss this case at Random Topics Follow trial on Twitter @thetrialfile
Day 1: live.freep.com